# What AI tech bros need to learn from Project Hail Mary

> What Project Hail Mary gets right about practical filmmaking, AI and telling hopeful stories.

Studio · Essay · March 23, 2026 · By Mehul Agarwal · 6 min read

![What AI tech bros need to learn from Project Hail Mary](https://koyal.ai/media/news/imported/HD-AIdNbYAAtBVS.jpg)

I admit the title is a bit clickbaity.

For context, I'm an AI tech bro building an AI company, but one that helps filmmakers use AI to create movies they never could without insane budgets. So this is really just my review of the movie, and what I learned from it.

The promise of this movie was too great to ignore. @andyweirauthor is amongst my favorite sci-fi writers of all time alongside @kyliu99 (All That We See or Seem) and @ErnestCline (Ready Player One).

If you haven't read The Egg, do yourself a favor and read it right now. It takes ten minutes but will make you think for at least ten hours.

@RyanGosling is also one of the best actors of this generation. Also he is literally me. So I had to see it day zero to watch myself save humanity.

Here are my lessons from what felt like the first feel-good space movie I've seen in a long, long time. (Minor spoilers ahead, but nothing that ruins the movie.)

## You don't have to put AI in everything

![Ryan interacting with the ship manually rather than just via voice commands or prompts lol](https://koyal.ai/media/news/imported/HEIMWhxaIAAnK9M.jpg)

*Ryan interacting with the ship manually rather than just via voice commands or prompts lol*

Ryland Grace doesn't interact with AI much in the movie. His spaceship has an intelligent AI that can talk him through things, but we rarely see them chatting.

That silence adds to his isolation. So by the time Rocky comes along, you feel him discovering life again. The joy of talking to someone that feels real, not artificial.

The book came out in 2021, clearly pre-GPT. But sci-fi authors have imagined conversational AI for a long time: "Her" came out in 2013. So this was a deliberate choice: keep the ship's AI quiet, keep the protagonist truly alone.

If it were written now, that ship AI would definitely be powered by Claude. But I'm glad Lord and Miller kept the book's aesthetic: AI as infrastructure, not a character. If Ryland were constantly chatting with the AI, you'd lose the emotional crux: that in space, he is truly alone.

It would be a completely different movie if Ryland had been chatting with an AI companion the whole time and then Rocky appeared. Interesting, but different.

(It would be very interesting to see a film showing a human talking to an artificial life is very different than talking to an alien life. I wonder if someone's writing that right now lol)

And even though the tech is sci-fi, Rocky doesn't get an LLM pass to smooth out his speech. His language translating to broken English is what makes him endearing. "Amaze, amaze, amaze" hits so much harder than an AI translating it to "Yes, you're absolutely right. This is amazing."

## It's better to go Analog.

![Rocky was a puppet!!](https://koyal.ai/media/news/imported/HEIMd-ZaYAAWD7-.jpg)

*Rocky was a puppet!!*

One of the best things about Andy Weir is how grounded his sci-fi is. Everything feels just over the brink of being possible. The costumes, the set, the ship controls. All analog. You're in a ship traveling close to light speed, but it still feels possible today.

Sci-fi doesn't need to be beyond our understanding to be science fiction.

This carries over to how they shot the film. No blue or green screens. All practical sets. That's amazing.

Having a puppeteer for Rocky made him feel way more alive than a full CG body would have.

I do think they overdid the "we didn't use CG" narrative (slightly ironic from the creators behind Spider-Verse). There was plenty of CG to hide wires, puppeteers, and other effects, and those artists deserve credit too. But shooting practically made the story feel more alive.

I see this in my own industry: people want AI to replace everything in movies. But hybrid filmmaking is the way to go. Use AI for what would be insanely expensive or impossible to shoot. Don't replace the entire art of filmmaking.

There was one sequence I was shocked to learn was shot practically: the infrared capture scene. Visually stunning.

![This scene was captured practically?!](https://koyal.ai/media/news/imported/HEIMne9aIAAcG6S.jpg)

*This scene was captured practically?!*

## It's ok to be inspired & pay homage to old media.

![Project Hail Mary actively uses the space vlog format popularized by The Martian](https://koyal.ai/media/news/imported/HEIQ0DjaIAIpB7F.jpg)

*Project Hail Mary actively uses the space vlog format popularized by The Martian*

They kept Ryan making vlogs to capture his experience. Clearly inspired by Matt Damon in The Martian (both Andy Weir, so it makes sense).

They could have easily had future versions of @circlebackai or @meetgranola capture his day automatically. But Ryan recording vlogs himself made the film more engaging and more human.

Among many easter eggs: in a pivotal karaoke scene, Sandra Hüller sings "Sign of the Times" by Harry Styles.

The unedited lyrics took on a completely different meaning. "Breaking through the atmosphere" and "We gotta get away from here" directly signal the film's central conflict on Earth.

Sign of the Times is itself an ode to 70s British rock. Now it's being paid homage from "the future," evoking layered nostalgia. It doesn't feel out of place because it's done tastefully.

A lot of companies are using AI replicas of Hollywood actors and locations to "promote" their startups without consent. It's fun to see short term, but there's no taste in copy-pasting likenesses to sell a product.

Done tastefully, inspiration and nostalgia hit hard. Done badly, you become the laughing stock of the internet.

![Universally panned Superbowl Xfinity Jurassic Park Commercial with a digitally de-aged Neill, Dern, and Goldblum](https://koyal.ai/media/news/imported/HEIQZ7Ga8AA6ty1.jpg)

*Universally panned Superbowl Xfinity Jurassic Park Commercial with a digitally de-aged Neill, Dern, and Goldblum*

## You can have Utopian outcomes in Dystopian Settings

![The film had a team of scientists from across the world (and planets) work together](https://koyal.ai/media/news/imported/HEINBe8aMAA64Tl.jpg)

*The film had a team of scientists from across the world (and planets) work together*

As my friend @EeshaAgarwal2 put it, what the film portrayed well was HOPE.

The conflict was world-ending, but the film never had a doomer mentality. We knew the stakes were high (this was literally a "Hail Mary") which is exactly why we rooted for him. And the film quietly assured us things would work out, because what's the point of a world-ending threat if the protagonist can't solve it?

It didn't shy away that the future was going to have massive problems but throughout the entire movie, there was hope. And even though most of the movie was about Ryland Grace and Rocky, there was a sense of collaboration.

The film didn't shy away from a future full of massive problems, but hope ran through every frame. And even though most of the movie centers on Ryland and Rocky, there's a deeper sense of collaboration.

On Earth, the smartest people and nations working together on paradigm-shifting tech; in space, two individuals from different planets coming together to save their worlds.

Too often, dystopian settings lead to dystopian outcomes in sci-fi.

I love that humor was a big part of the movie. It's crazy to me that Gravity, which had much lower stakes, was grimmer than this movie where the Sun is literally being eaten.

That's what tech bros building AI should think about. How do we use it to make an already broken world more hopeful? Not to replace jobs or upend everything, but to make things better.

In a way, this was the antithesis of "Don't Look Up" by Adam Mckay: great cast, but a very on-the-nose critique of humanity.

We already know the world is in trouble. Instead of critiquing, let's add a cultural glint of hope and optimism.

If the world we live in is already a Black Mirror episode, our movies should be the opposite.

That's what we're exploring at @KoyalAI: using AI not to replace filmmakers, but to augment their stories.

Project Hail Mary reportedly cost $190M to make. We believe the next generation of stories like this will have similar visuals without that price tag. We want to enable directors across the world to make movies at this scale without needing Hollywood budgets.

And we want to help visionary directors like Lord and Miller go even bigger. And yes, to release Spider-Verse: Beyond the Spider-Verse faster.

![What AI tech bros need to learn from Project Hail Mary](https://koyal.ai/media/news/imported/HEIY3csaMAAgpMc.jpg)

## Sources

- [What AI tech bros need to learn from Project Hail Mary](https://x.com/meh_agarwal/status/2036213224593653765) — Mehul Agarwal on X. Originally published on X.

Published in [Koyal News](https://koyal.ai/news). Canonical page: https://koyal.ai/news/what-ai-tech-bros-need-to-learn-from-project-hail-mary
